Home Theater View

TCL A1: TCL Cautiously Enters the Portable Projector Market

TCL is an enormous, vertically integrated TV manufacturer: TCL runs its own factories and invests tens of billions of dollars in building its own display panel fabs in China. (TCL also has enormous mobile and home appliance divisions.) Like most big brands, TCL initially ignored the surge of portable projectors out of China because they didn't initially target TV buyers, but it is now dipping its toes into the market as the product category grows and we start seeing some cannibalization of traditional entertainment displays. TCL is late to this trend; Samsung went first with the Freestyle launched at the Covid CES in early 2022, and LG joined last year with the CineBeam. With the $500 TCL A1, TCL is trying to find an entry point in the small projector market that balances its reputation for picture quality and value.

 

TCL gets off to a spectacular -- if not terribly sustainable -- start with its packaging. Opening up the cardboard shipping box you get a thick Styrofoam inner case that not only protects the projector but acts as a carrying case in the future, complete with attached shoulder strap. Unfortunately, while it is reusable, the styrofoam is not recyclable, and the packaging also involves plenty of single-use plastic bags and protective film. Still, the out of box experience feels premium.

 

The carrying handle pushes all the way through the housing to act as a stand for tilting up to 15 degrees. Using it engaged the auto keystone feature, which was effective. There is definitely a hit to the projector's 1080p resolution when using keystone, but it was not as bad as the Yaber T2.

 

This is TCL's first projector, and the company leaned in on picture quality and value at the expense of brightness. TCL only specs the A1 at 360 ANSI lumen -- even with the lights off, it's not a particularly bright picture and HDR is not supported at all. However, with the lights out, color is excellent and contrast is good. I watched the opening sequence of Marvelous Mrs. Maisel S3E1 and the USO showgirls' costumes looked wonderfully rich and saturated while the American flag backdrop had just the right amount of desaturation to look realistic. Even with keystoning, objects and people in sharp focus were clear. However, turn the room lights on and the picture gets badly washed out. You could use the TCL A1 for sports with the lights halfway up but I really wouldn't recommend it. Similarly, despite TCL's marketing materials, I wouldn't use the A1 as an outdoor movie night projector unless it is actually fully dark, especially since people tend to push image size to the maximum when watching outside.

 

This smart projector runs Google TV, making setup straightforward with the Google Home app. Unfortunately, the on-screen guide skips a step -- just opening the Google Home app isn't enough to get you to the QR code scanning stage, you need to manually tell the app to set up a new device. Next, you'll need to download a 1.17 GB firmware update. Download speeds were dismal when I tested it, taking nearly an hour for full setup despite my gigabit Fios connection; it could have been a server issue, but more likely the projector's slow Wi-Fi and storage. Make sure that you unbox and set this up the day before the big game or you might miss it.

One odd feature in Google TV that I somehow had to set up twice (once in the app, and then again on the projector's setup wizard) is a flexible screensaver that can display artwork or your choice of different Google Photo albums. This is a great feature on Google Home smart displays and traditional TVs, but who is going to leave the lights off and the projector on for a screen saver to make sense?

 

The remote control features quick access buttons for Netflix and Amazon Prime Video. Navigating Amazon Prime was especially slow and frustrating on the A1; at times I couldn’t be sure if my button presses had registered. There is also an HDMI input around back on the A1 for game consoles and media players.

 

The TCL A1 features dual 8w Dolby speakers that offer some limited stereo separation for the person sitting directly behind it, but not off to the side. The projector's fan noise is relatively low, and the speakers don't have to work hard to mask it for basic TV and movie sound. That's good, because while the A1 can play loud, the speakers distort when played at higher volumes and there isn't much bass. That isn't unusual for a projector of this size, but TCL is pitching the A1 as a Bluetooth speaker -- with flashing RGB lights on the side! -- and it just isn't a very good one.

 

This is a transportable projector, not a portable one. It must be plugged in at all times, and a big, heavy power brick sits in between the projector and the outlet.

 

For its first product in a new category, TCL was fairly cautious with the A1, and the result is something the company can build on. The A1 doesn't push the envelope much, but it gets many of the basics right: Google TV provides a solid foundation, the industrial design looks nice in a family room, it ships in its own case, and it has a pleasing picture provided you use it in a room with full light control. However, at $500 it isn't cheap, the audio could be better, and many customers in this category will want more light output, more portability, or both.

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Disclosure: TCL provided the A1 for review. TCL did not sponsor this review and Home Theater View does not accept affiliate payments. Home Theater View is a Techsponential company; TCL has been a Techsponential advisory services client in the past.

Yaber T2 Keith Haring Edition

Portable cannister projectors are not only becoming a big business, they allow small companies like XGIMI or (what was a small company) Anker/Nebula to move up the value chain. These companies, mostly coming out of China have names that you may not have heard of that nevertheless have sold hundreds of thousands or even millions of devices. Yaber was formed in 2018, shipped its first projector in 2019, and claims it hit over two million units sold by 2022. As it moves upmarket, Yaber sought out stylistic collaborators to stand out, and it launched a Keith Haring version of one of its larger portable projectors in 2024 partly covered with the late illustrator's iconic pop graffiti figures.  

I picked up a review unit of Yaber's T2 Keith Haring edition at IFA in Europe, and when I went to test it in the U.S., the first challenge was finding a plug converter kit (units sold in the U.S. should come with the appropriate plugs in the box; all can run on 100 - 240V). I had one in my travel bag, so that didn't take long, but it set the tone for what was to follow. In the U.S., Yaber is selling the base T2 model for $340 or as the T2 Plus for $400 with a Google TV dongle. The Keith Haring Edition is only sold in the Plus version in the U.S., which is a good idea (see below), also for $400, so there is no upcharge for the artwork. My press version also included a wonderful Keith Haring carrying case, which does not appear to be on sale in the U.S. at all. That's a shame. 

The good:

• Setup was straightforward. The carrying handle doubles as an angled stand and auto-keystoning worked well to center the image on my projection screen. (Most users will have a blank wall rather than a proper projection surface, but that should be even easier.)
• The Keith Haring designs on the projector are delightful and yet are somewhat restrained -- this looks like a projector with artwork on portions of it to add character, not a distracting art piece. That's crucial for something that is supposed to disappear when you are watching content.
• The JBL speaker in the T2 is clear and plays loud enough to be heard over the fan. Yaber includes a Bluetooth speaker mode, and I can absolutely see people using this that way.
• Yaber allows for physical HDMI connection and casting via app or NFC.
• Yaber built the power supply into the unit itself -- no bulky power brick lying halfway to the outlet.
• There is an internal battery that is spec'd at 2.5 hours so this can be fully wireless.

The bad:

• Unfortunately, once I tilted the projector up enough for the keystoning to work, the 1080p starting resolution dropped enough to be noticeable. The image was reasonably bright (it is spec'd at 450 ANSI lumens), but not terribly sharp. The colors were not especially well saturated, even with my lights off. If you buy this projector, make sure to put it on a stand or counter that is tall enough for the image to hit the wall without needing much keystoning. You'll probably also want to use an off-white 
• This is a non-smart projector. You will need to either connect it to an HDMI source, buy the version with the Google TV dongle, or cast content from your phone or laptop.
• I had some difficulty casting content to the projector from my Samsung Galaxy S25. It isn't using Google's own tech, so there are a million different permissions you need to set, and at the end of the process I managed to stream photos from Google Photo and videos stored on my phone using the VLC media player but not Disney+. This is not surprising; copyright material generally can't be streamed to devices.
• This is a portable projector with a nicely integrated carrying handle, and the press version of the Keith Haring Edition came with a great padded travel case. However, the Yaber T2 is a lot bigger than cannister projectors that are far more portable. That, and the fact that you're probably going to want to plug in a media or game device via HDMI, make it not nearly as portable as other options that are fully integrated.

• 
• 
• 

The Yaber T2 costs $340 (or $400 with a Google TV dongle), which is more than reasonable for the specs, but not for the picture quality I saw in my testing.

 

Disclosure: Yaber provided the T2 Keith Haring Edition for review. HomeTheaterView has no financial relationship with Yaber and does not accept affiliate payments.

Bose is Buying McIntosh

Bose announced that it is buying historic amplifier and speaker brand McIntosh Group from its private equity owners for undisclosed terms. McIntosh Group also includes high-end speaker brand Sonus Faber. This acquisition is about three things:

1. McIntosh gives Bose entry into luxury brands/opportunities, especially for its already successful automotive audio business

2. High-end audio is a difficult standalone business; there has been relentless consolidation throughout the industry, and McIntosh's owners were likely looking for an exit. 

3. Bose tech enables McIntosh to get into mobile / personal products. I would expect to see a McIntosh headphones announcement, or possibly IEMs (in-ear monitors) in the next 18 - 24 months as a result.  

Here's the press release: https://www.bose.com/pressroom/bose-acquires-mcintosh-group-announcement

LG MyView Smart Monitor: A 4K TV for Those Who Also Need a Premium PC Monitor

LG’s MyView Smart Monitor combines a 32" 4KTV, a 32" PC monitor, and an OS that theoretically allows you to do light computing. This is not a random combination, or simply about space saving, it reflects the reality that work, personal computing, and entertainment share key technical similarities and are often done in a shared space. I spent a few months with the 32” MyView Smart Monitor (32SR85U) to see how well LG has addressed each use case individually, whether a converged product makes sense, and, if so, whether LG’s approach is the right one. This review will focus on the TV and PC monitor aspects; for more on why it fails as a computing platform and market analysis, check out my report at Techsponential.

MyView: A 32” 4K Smart TV

The MyView Smart Monitor is a good TV for small spaces. It starts with industrial design and inclusion of a TV remote control. While many desk monitors are intended to be viewed only head-on, LG gave the MyView an attractive white plastic shell even around back that won’t look out of place in a kitchen or family room. (The black-on-white compliance logos on the webcam and the lack of a cover for the ports are the only real misses.) The MyView remote control has quick access buttons for Netflix, Amazon Prime Video, and Disney+, along with LG Channels. The MyView remote control uses infrared instead of Bluetooth or proprietary RF schemes, but in practice this wasn’t an issue; the emitter appears to be quite powerful and the remote doesn’t need to be pointed directly at the monitor to work. The MyView is also LG Magic Remote Compatible, adding an air pointer and voice control capabilities. Techsponential’s reference TV is an LG C2 OLED with a Magic Remote; it’s fine, but MyView owners won’t be missing enough to justify a separate accessory purchase.

The MyView does not have an OTA HDTV tuner, but LG uses webOS across its smart TV line, so there is solid app support for all the big streaming options. Apple AirPlay 2 and HomeKit compatibility allow casting content from iOS or MacOS devices without an Apple TV. There is also a webOS Divx HD player for playing video files off of USB memory sticks. Still, the internal apps or casting are the best ways to get content to the monitor as there are just two HDMI inputs, and neither supports eARC.

I watched several episodes of Agatha All Along using the embedded Disney+ app and was mostly satisfied. Resolution was good enough to tell when the cast was approaching a forbidding castle; you could see where the road set ended and the green screen CGI started. The MyView’s colors shift significantly when viewed vertically off-axis, and the image gets washed out. Fortunately, this is also a desk monitor, so it is unlikely to matter in the real world: nobody is going to mount this over a fireplace – but you should keep this in mind if you plan to mount it higher or lower than eye level.

Like most modern flat panel televisions, the included speakers cannot reproduce much bass, and the midrange and treble are tinny. A soundbar is highly recommended.

However, considered just as a 32” TV, at $600, it is wildly more expensive than other small 4KTVs (Sony and Samsung have 32” 4KTVs at $500 before sales, and 42” 4KTVs start around $140). Unless you specifically need a 32” 4K set (and not 42”) and value use as a PC monitor, the pricing won’t make sense.

MyView: A 32” 4K computer monitor

The LG MyView is an excellent monitor for productivity and light content creation. The 31.5” 16:19 IPS panel has a claimed 178 degree viewing angle, and although there is definite color shift off-axis, the image is sharp and colors render nicely when connected to Windows or MacOS laptops. Color gamut is specified at DCI-P3 95%; while this isn’t designed for professional color grading, it should be excellent for productivity and content creation. There’s a nice anti-glare coating. In direct comparisons I found that it’s not quite as good as the $200 nano-texture option for the M4 iMac, but it is still effective at reducing glare. The MyView’s listed 1,000:1 contrast ratio appears accurate: black levels don’t approach OLED, but then neither does the price point. The MyView has HDR10, and at 400 nits I was able to see some specular highlights, but HDR is not this monitor’s forte.

Gray-to-gray refresh response time is claimed at 5ms, which is fine, but refresh rates top out at 60Hz, so this monitor won’t work for serious gamers. The fixed 60Hz refresh rate on both MyView monitors hurts LG’s case for converged entertainment with a gaming laptop, PC, or current generation game console. I suspect that if the current MyView line gets an upgrade for 2025, that is where LG will focus improvements.

The stand moves up or down by a few inches and tilts slightly forward and backwards; there is a VESA mount if you need more flexibility. You can connect a PC via HDMI or USB-C; an HDMI cable is included, but not a USB 3.2 Type-C Gen 2 cable, which you’ll need if you want a single connection that also powers a laptop at up to 90 watts. I did not have one on hand, so I tested the monitor over HDMI.

The inclusion of speakers is a bonus for a computer monitor. It lacks bass and fullness for music, but it’s a nice inclusion for things like YouTube instructional videos.

The magnetically attached webcam unfortunately is not accessible by connected PC’s (possibly unless you have that USB 3.2 Type-C Gen 2 cable). In my testing it was only available to the internal webOS apps – more on this below.

$600 is on the high end of the price range for a 32” 4K IPS monitor that only refreshes at 60Hz and lacks NVIDIA and AMD anti-tearing technology for gaming. However, the anti-reflective coating, reasonable brightness, good color reproduction, and internal speakers all add value. If this were just a computer monitor, it would be a bit overpriced, but not unreasonable.

However, LG also sells a similar monitor/TV combo that has many of the same features, the MyView 32SR73U, for $380. It lacks the webcam and only supports 65w over USB, has slightly less accurate color reproduction (DCI-P3 90% vs 95%), doesn’t have an anti-glare coating, and it isn’t as bright (250 nits vs 400). The consolation is that the contrast ratio is higher (3000:1 vs 1000:1). While the monitor itself isn’t as nice, as a combination product for roughly the same price as more basic 4K monitors or 4KTVs, that one will makes sense to many more buyers.

 

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Conclusion

With the MyView Smart Monitor 32SR85U, LG is trying to combine three products in one: a relatively large 4K computer monitor, a relatively small smart TV, and a light computing platform, just add keyboard and mouse. LG succeeds at two out of three: it’s an especially nice productivity monitor, a reasonable TV, and a miserable computing platform. It makes sense for those who have shared spaces for work and entertainment like a home office/guest room or kitchen workstation.

Disclosure: LG sent over the MyView for review. HomeTheaterView has no financial relationship with LG and does not accept affiliate payments. A market analysis version of this review was also published at Techsponential: HomeTheaterView is a Techsponential company.

Review: LG CineBeam Q

by Avi Greengart

The market for portable cannister pico-projectors is still niche, but it has attracted the attention of larger brands like Samsung and LG. LG’s first entry strikes a nice balance between performance and design. LG’s take on the portable smart projector leans heavily on design, with premium specs for the category, but still aiming at plug-and-play use cases rather than full-on home theater. The CineBeam Qube HU710PB (which LG blessedly refers to as “CineBeam Q,” so I will, too) is a relatively compact rectangle with a rotating stand that doubles as a carrying handle. LG has finished the CineBeam Q entirely in polished metal, and the circles and squares esthetic gives it a modern-steampunk vibe that is unique to the category – and significantly more attractive than anything else out there.

Specs and Setup

The CineBeam Q features DLP with 4K resolution and a laser light engine that puts out 500 lumen with 450,000:1 contrast ratio. Focus is motorized but zoom is fixed – if you want the picture to be bigger or smaller, move the projector closer or farther away from the wall or screen (more on this later). LG uses webOS across its consumer video product lines. I’ve been covering consumer electronics long enough to have been featured in Palm’s original press release for the first webOS phone, and I haven’t always been a fan of its current use on TVs. webOS drives me nuts on my C2 77” OLED 4KTV because that TV is fed by multiple sources through an A/V receiver, and I just want the TV to act as a dumb monitor and webOS wants to be an entire computing and entertainment system. But on the CineBeam Q, webOS is a major positive over limited Android TV implementations: all the major streaming apps are available, including Netflix. webOS starts up quickly, too, eliminating the wait you usually have on Android TV projectors before you can get to content.

A 3 watt mono speaker is built in, and if that seems underpowered, it is. The built-in speaker does a reasonable job with clarity and tone, but it is clearly mono, there is no soundstage, and it doesn’t get all that loud. I found this to be one of the big drawbacks of the CineBeam Q. LG is bundling the XBOOM 360 XO2TBK, a 360 degree Bluetooth speaker, with the projector if you buy it directly from LG. In a demo at LG’s US headquarters, that was a great combination. In my home without the speaker, the CineBeam Q was hard to hear over its fan and my air conditioner, and provided nothing like a cinematic audio experience.

Unlike most cannister projectors, the CineBeam Q does not have an internal battery. The good news is that you’ll never have to charge it up or discover that your projector can’t make it through Oppenheimer in a single sitting. The bad news is that you need to have a power source nearby. Many people buy cannister projectors to use outdoors, and this requirement could make that difficult.

Setup requires an LG account, which requires you to give LG the ability to track and resell what you’re watching (if there is a way to get out of this, I didn’t see it). I also found setup extremely frustrating using the remote control until I realized that the infrared emitter on the remote is terribly weak; you must point the remote directly at the back of the projector rather than towards the content. Even after setup, I still encountered times when I didn’t point the remote at precisely the correct angle for my selection to register. IR emitters are a 10-cent part, and it seems that LG was willing to hurt usability to save 5-cents instead.

Unboxing the LG CineBeam Q

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Performance

All projectors have fans, and manufacturers advertise how quiet they are on their lowest setting (25db according to LG’s website). When I tested it in real world conditions, I wasn’t as impressed. It’s not loud compared to actual loud things, but I measured 42.5db three feet away from the seating position. The fan noise is definitely noticeable, and I found the pitch of the sound somewhat distracting during quiet passages even after I connected the CineBeam Q to my full home theater surround sound system.

Traditional projectors have lens shift to allow you to perfectly line up your image with a fixed or retractable screen. Portable projectors are less finnicky about their placement: they use fixed lenses and automatic digital keystoning to adjust the image to whatever surface you point them at, from any angle. This process sacrifices resolution for convenience, and as these cannister projectors are typically meant for more casual use, not cinephile purists, that tradeoff is understandable. The auto keystoning on XGIMI and Nebula projectors are slightly faster and more flexible, but LG’s implementation should be good enough for how most people use smart projectors. That said, when pointed at my 100” screen off-axis, I could easily see the loss of clarity down from its full 4K resolution.

No projector works well in a brightly lit room. However, for just a 500 nit projector, I was surprised by the apparent brightness with moderate room light control. LG advertises a staggering 450,000:1 contrast ratio, and while it didn’t make blacks into true black, the CineBeam Q provides excellent shadow detail in a dark room. Colors are another highlight: in Cinema Mode, the colors are well saturated, and when watching Amazon Prime Video’s Fallout, I could tell where the action was taking place just based on the color palette.

Comparisons 

I tested two other projectors alongside the LG CineBeam Q to see where it fits: my old Sony VPL-HW40ES, a 1080p SXRD projector spec’d at 1700 lumen, and XGIMIs Horizon Ultra, a dual LED/laser 4K HDR projector that puts out 2300 lumen. To give the projectors the best chance to shine (pun intended), I watched Encanto on 4K Blu-ray disc on all three. The Sony may be spec’d at 1700 lumen, and the colors are pleasing, but black levels are awful and cinema mode looked relatively dim on my 100” 1.1 gain screen. (I paid $2000 for this projector less than ten years ago. Sigh.) In comparison, the LG was shockingly good: much brighter, with greater color saturation and sharper resolution, despite being slightly off-center and the Sony having been permanently mounted and aligned on my ceiling. With some lights on, the picture looks acceptable; with lights off, the image pops like an LED TV (the CineBeam is still not quite as bright as miniLED or as contrasty as OLED). With full lights on, the image is viewable, but just barely. It is a projector, after all. Keep this in mind if you plan on using this to watch sports – some light control is necessary. The XGIMI is simply in a different class: it costs $500 more than the LG and isn’t really portable. Resolution, color fidelity, and highlights on the XGIMI Horizon Ultra are noticeably better in all lighting conditions. 4K HDR version colors become iridescent, contrast increases, and it looks like there’s significantly more detail in the image compared to the LG.

Conclusion

The CineBeam Q’s fan is a bit too loud, its speaker is not loud enough, and at $1300, it is on the pricey side for a 4K projector that only puts out 500 lumen. However, you get better-than-specs-would-suggest brightness and color from an incredibly stylish design with one of the best TV OS for streaming. There are no hoops to jump through to get Netflix running – there’s even a Netflix button on the remote. And it’s so pretty that you could leave it out on a coffee table all the time.

Disclosure: LG sent over the CineBeam Q for review. HomeTheaterView has no financial relationship with LG and does not accept affiliate payments. A market analysis version of this review was also published at Techsponential: HomeTheaterView is a Techsponential company.

Upgrading to Denon AVR-X8500HA -- is an "A" Worth $600?

By Avi Greengart

My home theater serves a test bed for various devices for Techsponential and Home Theater View, and while I was able to test the latest display resolutions on TVs in my soundbar test rigs, my main home theater setup was based on a Denon AVR-X8500H with older HDMI inputs. My main game console is an XBOX Series X and my reference display is an LG C2 OLED 4KTV, so I already had the content and display to fully support 4K/120 gaming, I was just lacking the thing in the middle to connect them while providing extensive surround sound.

Most solid-state electronics are essentially disposable these days, but Denon deserves credit for making the AVR-X8500H somewhat modular: there is a $600 upgrade package that swaps out the HDMI board and turns it into an AVR-X8500HA with (limited) 8K/60 and 4K/120 support (the AVR-X8500HA when sold on its own lists for $4700). I also considered selling my receiver and upgrading to Denon's new flagship, the AVR-A1H. That unit is a monster, with 15 amplifier channels and a $6500 price tag to match. I told Denon PR that I'd be interested in checking out an AVR-A1H when they have review units available, but I can't use the extra amp channels -- my theater room is too small to add a third row of in-ceiling Atmos speakers -- and I can't justify purchasing one at this time. The AVR-X8500H HDMI 2.1 upgrade board has been listed as $600 and "coming in April 2024" on Denon's site for over a year. It still reads that way today, but in June 2024 the site let me put it in my cart and buy it, so I crossed my fingers and hoped for the best. 

So what do you get when you spend $600 to add an "A" to the AVR-X8500H? Part of the cost goes towards shipping. Denon does not allow end users to perform the upgrade themselves, so an authorized repair center mails you a box to send the 60 lb package to them and then back again to you. The packaging double-boxes the receiver but provides absolutely no guidance whatsoever on next steps. You need to figure out that you're supposed to break apart the styrofoam, place it in specific spots, place the receiver inside -- without antennas or remote control -- seal it up with packing tape (not included), and call FedEx Ground for a pickup. The service center was just as confused as I was -- a rep called to ask what repairs were needed. Denon has a lot of work to do on this experience - from website to packaging to service center processes.

The good news is that the process took less time than I expected -- I was only without a receiver for about a week Once I got the unit back, it looked like they replaced the entire front panel -- with new stickers attached! -- in addition to the new HDMI 2.3 internals around back. There were no changes to the 13 amplifier channels or processing but those are still pretty close to state of the art, so it's not missing much in that regard. At the end of the day, all the HDMI inputs were updated to HDCP2.3, but there is only a single 8K input. That input is also the only 4K/120 input, so if you want to connect both an Xbox Series X and a Playstation 5, you're out of luck. The last console Sony sent over is a Playstation 4 PRO, so that isn't an issue I'm currently facing, but Denon's newer receivers support 8K on all inputs, so that could be a dealbreaker for some.

Once back in my rack, it took me a while to figure out that you need to enable 8K support in the Denon's menu to support 4K/120, that only the 8K input supports 4K/120, and that there are similar settings that need to be enabled on the Xbox and TV. But somewhere between 3AM and 4AM I had Forza 6 working in 4K/120 on my 77" OLED with full surround sound. Despite the improved refresh rate I almost immediately plowed my virtual Subaru into the virtual wall at the virtual Nürburgring racetrack.

Was it worth it? Given how expensive it would be to sell and buy an equivalent receiver (or processor and amps) for my 9.4.2 channel Dolby Atmos system, it was a cost-effective upgrade. However, given the limitations of just a single fully futureproof 8K/4K120 input, it's probably only a matter of time before I need to do a full replacement.

• 
• 
• 
• 

HomeTheaterView is a Techsponential company and does not accept advertising or affiliate payments. Equipment reviews/purchases disclosure:
Denon AVR-X8500H was originally purchased direct from Denon at a discount for reviewers.
The HDMI 2.1 upgrade package was purchased direct from Denon at full retail price. 
The Xbox Series X is a long-term review unit sent by Microsoft. 
The LG 77" C2 OLED was purchased at retail.

Review: TCL QM8 Was a High Performance 4KTV Value in 2023; In 2024 It's a Bargain

By Avi Greengart

In 2023, TCL chose to push quantum dot and gaming features down its line but leave miniLED backlighting only on its higher-end QM8 line. At launch it was a strong value with great contrast and color for less than bigger brands. In 2024, prices have come down further and new TCL models have been announced, but the QM8 will remain on the market for a while -- and it's now a bargain.

Introduction

In the U.S., TCL is best known for its televisions, but it is actually one of the largest consumer electronics conglomerates in the world. TCL runs its own factories and invests tens of billions of dollars in building its own display panel fabs in China. TCL's mobile division sells Alcatel and TCL branded featurephones, smartphones, tablets, modems, and more. The parent company also makes washing machines, refrigerators, and consumer IoT devices that are primarily sold in Asia.

All that said, in the U.S., TCL really is primarily a television company, and it has grown at the expense of larger, better-known brands by following two simple strategies: maximizing the initially small budget it had for marketing, and providing a lot of value to consumers. As TCL’s panels grew in size – and the company moved slightly upmarket at retail – TCL paid up for the ultimate U.S. sports marketing rights: it is now the official TV of the NFL.

Sports may move the marketing needle, but gaming and streaming drive higher-priced TV sales. For 2023, TCL moved desirable gaming features and quantum dot color down into lower priced tiers, while reserving miniLED backlight technology for its higher end QM8 line. The QM8 starts at 55” but doesn’t stop at 75” or even 85” — you can get an absolutely enormous 98” miniLED QM8. Pricing on the QM8 line started out reasonably, with the 65” at $1300 and the 98” only $5,000, but holiday sales and time have pushed those prices down significantly. The 65” that TCL sent over is now $1,000, and the 98” monster is just $4,000.

Unboxing and First Impressions

The first thing I noticed when unboxing the TCL QM8 was the attention paid to the rear of the set. Typically, mainstream consumer televisions look clean on the front, but the back has multiple different scalloped segments, with exposed screws, lots of cheap plastic, and a cramped input area on one side. The QM8 will almost certainly end up on a wall mount or sitting on furniture close to the wall, but on the off chance that it will be placed in the middle of the room, TCL took the time to make the rear of the QM8 presentable. The whole back area is a sculpted curve, with port areas covered up, and an attractive bass speaker in the center. Other than the speaker, it doesn’t cost TCL much to do this, it’s more a matter of priorities: the attention to detail on the back is one way that TCL is pushing this set past budget value segments and towards more premium value buyers.

TCL licenses operating systems from Amazon, Roku, and Google; this set is an Android TV version. Android TV OS 11 is functional, with all the apps you’d expect, plus a reasonable amount of Google integration with YouTube, any content you’ve purchased from Google, and home control. It is not as straightforward an interface as Roku or as theatrical as Fire TV, but navigating the interface on the QM8 was responsive. That's good, because TCL does not note which MediaTek chip it uses in the QM8 -- or even acknowledge that it is using one (it is). In contrast, Sony boasts that its (admittedly more expensive) Bravia Mini LED TVs use premium MediaTek chips for better upscaling. At least whatever TCL is using in the QM8 doesn't hold it back from responsive day to day use.

The QM8’s remote control is long and rounded. It fits nicely in your hand and is straightforward to use, but it is not backlit, the buttons are not overly differentiated by shape, and only the power, channel up/down, and volume up/down buttons have raised indicators to feel for. Like most TVs today – and all budget brands – TCL sells one-touch placement buttons on the remote to streaming channels. Netflix, Prime Video, YouTube, and Apple TV are joined by TCL’s own TCL TV+ channel – ad-supported streaming linear TV, and TCL Home – a quick settings bar with its own login. TCL is hardly alone in trying to build an ad business around its TVs, but at least for the programming I watched, TCL doesn’t have a large advertising base just yet – each ad break repeated the same spots multiple times.

Performance

The QM8 is one of the first televisions I’ve had in for review that didn’t immediately make me turn to the Sonos Arc soundbar I have on my test stand. That doesn’t mean that I left the soundbar off – this is still not especially rich or directional sound, music is a bit flat and dialog could certainly be clearer. The "ULTRA-BASS" branding on the rear speaker is aspirational. However, you can get reasonably loud and clear audio out of the QM8’s internal speaker array, and that isn’t always the case even at this price point. If you plan on using this for news, cooking shows, and sports, you should be able to get away without an external audio solution.

TCL is pushing gaming features down even into its budget line, but it certainly doesn’t stop there, and the QM8 is a great match for 5^th generation game consoles from Sony and Microsoft. It also makes a reasonable PC gaming monitor, if by reasonable you mean absolutely enormous. The set has a dedicated low latency gaming mode, supports variable refresh rate, and will let you play games at 4K 144Hz or 1080 at 240Hz. There are also modes that smooth motion even further (great for gaming, turn them off for content, please).

I’ve saved the best for last: picture quality. If you are sitting on-axis, the QM8’s miniLED backlight array and quantum dot color combine to create compelling images that approach OLED contrast with even brighter HDR (High Dynamic Range) highlights. This is a superb TV for rooms with large picture windows and equally good in a dark room watching prestige TV in Dolby Vision. The QM8 hits peak HDR near 2000 nits and supports every HDR format (unlike Samsung) including HDR10, HDR10+, HLG, and Dolby Vision. Dolby Vision IQ is included, which auto-adjusts to account for room lighting; I found it somewhat unpredictable and turned it off, preferring Dolby Vision Bright or Dark depending on room conditions.

The title sequence for Foundation on Apple TV+ is a great way to show off Dolby Vision high dynamic range (there are several concentrated lights), wide color gamut (the shifting color beads), contrast, and resolution (the crisp narrow font on top of all the rest). Shadow detail in Fallout on Amazon Prime is excellent, and all the over-the-top gore pops against the muted color tones of the wasteland. The “Family Madrigal” introductory song in Disney’s Encanto is essentially a color saturation torture test – and the QM8 passes with [sorry for the pun] flying colors. If you want to see just how bright the HDR can get on the QM8, you can’t do much better than the opening sequence in Disney’s Encanto – until you get to the “Waiting on a Miracle” number, which could have been animated by Dolby itself as Dolby Vision demo. The QM8 can also do atmospheric, moody content with accurate skin tones.

Like all LCD displays, when sitting off to the side, brightness and color varies significantly; in that situation, or if you simply want the best possible contrast and color reproduction, an OLED is worth paying for. I also wish that the glass was a bit less reflective; the QM8 can go super-bright and outshine reflections from room lamps and windows, but muting those room highlights would still make for easier watching.

Comparisons and Conclusion

I have an LG C2 OLED one room over in my main theater area, and if you don’t have an OLED nearby for direct comparison, you’re unlikely to notice a big drop-off in picture quality with the QM8 even on scenes with white text on dark backgrounds, HDR reflections, or animation with wide color gamut. You probably also won’t notice the technically wider color range that the best OLEDs can produce, at least not on normal program material. However, you will notice about $1,000 more in your wallet.

The TCL QM8 2023 is not as bright as the 2024 models are going to be, nor is it an OLED for the ultimate in contrast and off-axis viewing. But when compared to similar miniLED TVs from Samsung and LG, it offers superb performance at a lower price. This value proposition becomes even stronger when you get to larger sizes, topping out at a projector-like 98” for 2023, and still highly competitive in 2024.

 

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Disclosure: TCL sent over a 65" QM8 4KTV for review but HomeTheaterView has no financial relationship with TCL and does not accept affiliate payments. A market analysis version of this review was published at Techsponential. HomeTheaterView is a Techsponential company; Techsponential has done limited consulting work for TCL's mobile group in the past.